เสียงธรรม A journey to inner peace / Ven Ajahn Brahm

Why Ajahn Brahmavamso was excluded from the Wat Pa Phong Sangha
The Buddhist Channel, Nov 5, 2009



The following is a statement from Wat Pa Nanachat, explaining their reasons for the expulsion of Ajahn Brahmavamso from the Wat Pa Phong Sangha

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia -- Receiving ordination as a bhikkhu in Thailand, entails acceptance of the authority not only of the Vinaya, but also that of the Mahatherasamakom, (the Thai Sangha's governing body) and the laws of the land.

​

The Wat Pa Phong Sangha considers as a matter of course, that all of its members are ethically bound to respect their commitments to the Mahatherasamakom and to the Thai State.

Ajahn Brahmavamso deliberately and unilaterally performed a ceremony knowing it to be considered illegal by the Thai state, illegitimate by the Mahatherasamakom and thus unacceptable to the Wat Pa Phong Sangha. There could be little doubt that by doing so he was, in effect, turning his back on continued membership of the Wat Pa Phong Sangha

Wat Pa Phong and its branch monasteries constitute an informal grouping within the Thai Sangha. Membership of this group is voluntary and dependent on a willingness to conform to certain broad standards, most of which were established by Ajahn Cha.

They include dhutanga practices such as daily almsround and eating one meal a day from the almsbowl. Special allowances are granted for overseas monasteries and generally speaking, abbots are almost completely autonomous in the running of their own monasteries.

However, in the case that a monastery develops practices that significantly deviate from the Wat Pa Phong template, the matter is raised at the annual general meeting in June. The abbot in question is interviewed and asked to choose between the unacceptable practice or exclusion from the group. This procedure was followed in the case of Ajahn Brahmavamso with a meeting held on 1st November.

Exclusion from the Wat Pa Phong Sangha is primarily intended to maintain the harmony and integrity of the group. It is not a punitive measure, although in Thailand at least, exclusion may lead to a certain loss of prestige and material gains.

Ajahn Brahmavamso is unlikely to be adversely affected by the exclusion. His reputation and fund- raising activities may well be enhanced. His social ties with Wat Pa Phong were already weak. He has neglected relations with his Thai colleagues for some time now.

Over the last few years several of his trips to Thailand have been devoted to teaching laypeople without including visits to Ubon (most notably the one that coincided with the Wat Pa Phong annual general meeting of June 2009 in which the bhikkhuni issue was discussed).

The most common view of the Western theras (elders) is that Ajahn Brahmavamso had agreed to host a 'World Abbots Meeting (WAM) in December in which discussion of the bhikkhuni question was on the agenda. If he had waited until that meeting, and after talking things through, announced his decision to leave the WPP Sangha in order to follow a path he felt deeply to be correct and noble, his actions would have been considered regrettable but honourable.

In planning a bhikkhuni ordination for a couple of months before the WAM was to take place, in concealing his plans until a week before the ordination, and in carrying out the ceremony without speaking to either his preceptor, Somdet Buddhajahn, or the leader of the WPP Sangha, Luang Por Leeam beforehand at all, he acted in a way that suggested deceit and disrespect.

For most of the Wat Pa Phong theras, the intellectual argument over the validity of bhikkhuni ordination is not the point. Their lack of knowledge of the latest studies on the subject is, in their eyes, irrelevant.

To them the issue is that Ajahn Brahmavamso reneged on commitments implicit in his ownership of a Thai monastic passport, his role as abbot of a Wat Pa Phong branch monastery, his position as an officially sanctioned preceptor, and his acceptance of the Jow Khun title (formalizing his membership in the elite strata of the Thai monastic order).
In the meeting of the 1st November it was the perception that Ajahn Brahmavamso had acted disrespectfully to his teachers and lineage that aroused emotions, not his wish to elevate the status of women.

Time only will tell if the bhikkhuni ordination at Bodhinyana monastery in October 2009 will be seen as a key breakthrough in the acceptance of a Theravada bhikkhuni order, or as an overly hasty and confrontational move that alienated many of those it was intended to persuade.

Wat Pa Nanachat
:- https://www.buddhistchannel.tv/index.php?id=70,8661,0,0,1,0#.Y8Wq2-3MLIU

 

BUDDHIST SOCIETY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA - DHAMMALOKA CITY CENTRE
Friday Night Guided Meditation | Ajahn Brahm | 13 January 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Jan 15, 2023

 

Coffins and Living | Ajahn Brahm | 29-10-2010

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Oct 31, 2010
Ajahn Brahm gives a quirky talk about coffins and their relevance to life not death. Ajahn teaches us how to accept our karma, the nature of life and face our fears, such as death and sickness. Ajahn talks about understanding them, learning from them and even accepting and loving them. Ajahn says “Loving doesn’t mean we like it, loving is opening the door of your heart to everything because this is life and we can always find a beautiful perception about anything.”

 

BUDDHIST SOCIETY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA - DHAMMALOKA CITY CENTRE
Mind Made Worlds | Ajahn Brahm | 20 January 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Jan 20, 2023

 

'Kindfulness' / Ajahn Brahm

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Mar 9, 2013

 

Jealousy | by Ajahn Brahm | 15-11-2013

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Nov 16, 2013
Ajahn Brahm discusses the topic of jealousy and how to let it go.

 

A Taste of Freedom | Ajahn Brahm | 19-02-2010

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Apr 11, 2010
Ajahn Brahm offers a Buddhist perspective on what Freedom is and how it can be achieved. Ajahn gives us clarity on this spiritual subject he says is so misunderstood, yet so important in our lives. And he talks about how freedom of the heart is gained by meditation practice and letting go of control.

 

Trauma and Tragedy | Ajahn Brahm | 12-02-2010

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Apr 11, 2010
Ajahn Brahm offers advice on how best to deal with traumatic or tragic events and reminds us that ultimately we are responsible for our own happiness, even in tough times.

 

Beyond Boundaries / Ajahn Brahm

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Dec 1, 2013

 

The Process of Rebirth | Ajahn Brahm | 03-04-2009

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Apr 25, 2009

 

8 Between Observer & Observed - October 2011

BSWA Retreats 2011-15 & Media
Jun 24, 2012
9 day retreat from Ajahn Brahm's retreat.

 

Ajahn Brahm June 2015

BSWA Retreats 2011-15 & Media
Sep 10, 2015

 

Always do your best - Armadale Meditation Group | Ajahn Brahm | 17 January 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Jan 19, 2023

 

Accepting Life's Imperfections | Ajahn Brahm | 3 February 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Feb 3, 2023

 

Ven Ajahn Brahm's talk #3 Your relationship with the world Oct 22 2014

Dr. Arunika Gunawardena
Nov 22, 2014

 

Friday Night Guided Meditation | Ajahn Brahm | 3 February 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Feb 5, 2023

 

Living With Non-Buddhists | Ajahn Brahm | 21-01-2011

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Jan 22, 2011
How do you really practise Buddhism when everyone around you isn’t practising? Such as living as a Buddhist in a western country. Ajahn Brahm gives some practical advice for living with people who share different world views.

 

Hissing But Not Biting | Ajahn Brahm | 11-03-2011

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Mar 16, 2011

 

The Nature of Suffering | Ajahn Brahm | 10 February 2023

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Feb 10, 2023

 

Contentment | Ajahn Brahm | 11 Mar 2016

Buddhist Society of Western Australia
Mar 11, 2016